Buyer guide

Self-storage comps: how to build a rent and sales comp set

Comps drive every rent projection and every valuation. Here is how to pick the right competitors, which rates to trust, and what good comp data looks like.

Short answer: Self-storage comps are the competing facilities in a trade area that you use to set rents, project lease-up and value a deal. A strong comp set shows each competitor’s unit mix, street and web rates, promotions and occupancy, and, where available, achieved rents and NOI from reported financials.

Rent comps versus sales comps

TypeWhat it tells youUsed for
Rent compsWhat competitors charge by unit size and type, and how rates have movedRevenue projections, street-rate setting, lease-up assumptions
Occupancy and financial compsHow full competitors are and what they earnStabilized occupancy, expense ratios, NOI margin
Sales compsWhat similar facilities sold for or are listed at, per square footValuation, offer pricing, exit cap assumptions

How to build a comp set

  1. Draw the trade area. Start with 1, 3 and 5 mile rings around the subject. Tighten it in dense metros and widen it in rural markets.
  2. Include every competitor, not just the big brands. Independents often set the floor on rates in smaller markets.
  3. Match the product. Compare climate-controlled to climate-controlled and drive-up to drive-up, and note facility age, size and amenities.
  4. Compare like unit sizes. Line up 10x10 to 10x10 and convert to rent per square foot so different unit mixes compare fairly.
  5. Look at the trend, not just today. Rate history shows whether a market is gaining or losing pricing power.
  6. Check the pipeline. A new facility opening down the street will pressure rates during its lease-up.

Street, web and achieved rates

Street rates are what a facility advertises for new rentals. Web rates are the online price, often lower and paired with promotions. Achieved rates are what tenants actually pay across the facility, including existing customers who have had rate increases.

Street and web rates are visible every day, but they can understate or overstate revenue. Achieved rents and NOI from reported financials show what a facility really earns, which is why they matter most when you underwrite.

Where TractIQ comp data comes from

  • Daily street and web rates for all unit types, including promotions, across 68,000+ U.S. facilities
  • Facility-level rate history back to 2018
  • Verified occupancy, achieved rents and P&Ls on 4,000+ facilities from CMBS filings, monthly since 2017
  • Live listings uploaded by brokers, with price per square foot, for sales comps
  • The supply pipeline from permits aggregated nationwide

See occupancy data and the live listings for more.

Frequently asked questions

How many comps should a self-storage comp set include?

Most analysts use every direct competitor in the primary trade area, often five to fifteen facilities. Fewer than three gives you a thin read; too many pulls in facilities your tenants would never consider.

What radius should I use for self-storage comps?

A 3 mile ring is a common starting point, with 1 and 5 mile rings for context. Use a tighter radius in dense urban areas and a wider one in rural markets where customers drive farther.

What is the difference between street rates and achieved rates?

Street rates are advertised prices for new customers. Achieved rates are what all tenants actually pay, including existing customers after rate increases. Achieved rates are a truer measure of revenue.

Where can I find self-storage sales comps?

Sales comps come from recorded transactions and active listings. TractIQ shows live listings uploaded directly by brokers, with asking price and price per square foot, alongside the market data for each trade area.

How often do self-storage rates change?

Operators using revenue management can change rates daily. That is why comp data should refresh daily and include history, so you can tell a short-term promotion from a real trend.

See the data for your market

Book a 30-minute demo and a TractIQ analyst will walk through the facilities, rates, occupancy and pipeline in the trade area you care about.

Book a demo

Written by the TractIQ research team, led by Taylor Bills, Director of Research. Related: self-storage market intelligence software guide.